JUST IMAGINE! July 1956: A Whiff of Tear Gas No. 5

How many cancelled Golden Age superhero comics were later mined for Silver Age hits?

A lot.

And I’d argue that one of them was Harvey Comics’ Black Cat, an athletic crime-fighter who disappeared in 1951 and reappeared five years later at DC in the form of Batwoman.

As justification, DC could have cited the likelihood that DC characters had inspired Black Cat in the first place. Cross Batman with his friendly nemesis Catwoman and you’d be likely to come up with something like Black Cat, a heroine who debuted in Harvey’s Pocket Comics 1 (Aug. 1941).

DC editors must have noticed Black Cat’s healthy 10-year run, which included becoming a headliner in her own title. They might have wondered if a similar character could boost the Batman feature.

Shirley MacLaine as Bat Lady

Another inspiration may be found in a movie that appeared a year before Batwoman debuted in Detective Comics 233 (July 1956).

The girl behind the mask there was Shirley MacLaine in Artists and Models, a 1955 Paramount musical comedy with Martin and Lewis. Her character worked for a comic book publisher and served as the model for their top superhero, the Bat Lady. DC also published the licensed Adventures of Dean Martin & Jerry Lewis.

The original Batwoman was Kathy Kane, a wealthy former circus daredevil with a yen for adventure. Swinging from a trapeze, she muses, “I wish I could be like Batman, the greatest acrobat of all! He uses his skill, not for shows, but against crime!”

Donning a yellow-and-red costume and riding a Bat-cycle, she was an effective crime-fighter, although her tactics were weirdly “girly.” She captured crooks with feminine gadgets from her “utility purse” — expanding hairnets, charm bracelet handcuffs, “Tear Gas No. 5,” etc.

Given the tenor of the times, Batman, Robin and Superman were, of course, perpetually condescending to her.

“This is no place for a girl,” Batman told her in her debut adventure. “Please let me handle it!”

“No, I’ll stay, Batman,” she replied saucily. “I might have to save YOU again!”

In a scene that would be echoed in the 1992 film Batman Returns, Bruce Wayne and Kathy Kane end up dancing together at a society function.

“So she admires Batman!” Wayne thinks. “If only I could tell her I’m Batman — But I can’t!”

“Bruce is so good-looking — and he admires Batwoman!” Kathy thinks. “If — sigh, he only knew I’m Batwoman!”

Their romantic interlude is interrupted by that old mood-killer, the Bat-Signal.

In 1961, Batwoman was joined by her niece Betty Kane, who, discovering Kathy’s secret identity, managed to convince her aunt to let her become Bat-Girl.

Batwoman, Bat-Girl, Ace the Bat-Hound, Bat-Mite and various other batty ideas were discarded with Batman’s streamlined “New Look” in 1964, purportedly in the interests of “realism.” But a mere three years later, the Batwoman concept was revisited and revamped for another visual medium, providing a boost for the Batman TV show.

In the comics and on the show, Commissioner Gordon’s daughter Barbara became the mysterious Batgirl (no hyphen). She’s one of the better known of the surprisingly numerous Bat-females (a group that also includes Catwoman, the Huntress and yet another Batgirl, Cassandra Cain).

The original Batwoman was Vicki Vale’s rival, serving as a fresh romantic interest for Batman. Reintroduced as Kate Kane in August 2006, the new Batwoman reflected a new age. She had no romantic interest in men at all.

Some have suggested that Batwoman and Bat-Girl were introduced in part to mute McCarthy-era allegations that Batman and Robin were a homosexual wish-fulfillment fantasy. If so, then the reintroduction of Batwoman as a lesbian brought the whole situation full circle, ironically.

About Author